"Rogue," the sixth episode of Doctor Who's fourteenth series, takes a lighter approach, but its charm hides a surprisingly complex exploration of the Doctor's character. Set in a fantastical world resembling a Regency-era space opera, the episode throws the Doctor and Ruby into a whirlwind adventure with the enigmatic Rogue (Jonathan Groff).
A Delightful Romp: Written by Kate Herron and Briony Redman, the episode shines with witty dialogue and clever misdirects. The guest stars, particularly Groff, deliver strong performances, and the costumes are a visual feast. Overall, "Rogue" is a thoroughly enjoyable experience.
The Doctor's Sexy Shift: The episode subtly explores the Doctor's portrayal through Ncuti Gatwa's performance. This Doctor is undeniably charismatic, confident in his attractiveness, and uses it to disarm opponents. This flirty approach marks a departure from previous incarnations, who often displayed an endearing awkwardness in romantic situations.
Beyond the Surface: However, "Rogue" goes beyond just a charming facade. When faced with genuine emotional connection, the Doctor's confidence falters, revealing the familiar vulnerability beneath. This interplay between confidence and vulnerability creates a nuanced portrayal of the character.
A Well-Matched Guest Star: Jonathan Groff's nuanced performance as Rogue is a key element of the episode's success. Groff conveys a rich backstory with minimal dialogue, making Rogue a captivating and believable companion for the Doctor. Their chemistry is undeniable, from playful banter to a sizzling dance scene.
Raising the Stakes (Slightly Too High): The episode's only stumble comes in its sudden escalation to a world-ending threat. The Chulder, the initial bird-like villains, are entertainingly silly, but the motivation behind the final conflict feels rushed. Despite this, the emotional payoff of the ending remains strong due to the excellent performances.
Ruby's Growth: While Gatwa takes center stage, Millie Gibson delivers a strong performance as Ruby. Though relegated to a solo B-plot initially, she showcases Ruby's growing intelligence and emotional maturity. The quiet scene between Ruby and the Doctor after Rogue's departure is particularly heartwarming, solidifying their bond.
A Mysterious Cameo: "Rogue" also features a cryptic cameo from Susan Twist, this time as a seemingly judgmental painting. This appearance, coupled with her role in "Dot and Bubble," fuels speculation that Twist might be portraying the Valeyard, a classic Doctor Who villain.
A Call for Rogue's Return: "Rogue" is a delightful episode that leaves viewers wanting more. Groff's captivating performance and the undeniable chemistry between him and Gatwa make a strong case for Rogue's return. The episode also leaves intriguing threads dangling, particularly regarding Susan Twist's character. With only a few episodes left in the series, anticipation for the Doctor and Ruby's next adventure is high.