The seventh episode of "The Penguin," titled "Top Hat," is a game-changer that peels back the layers of Oswald Cobb's charming facade, revealing the darkness that lurks beneath. This episode is not for the faint of heart, as it delves deep into the psyche of Gotham's most enigmatic crime lord, and it's essential to approach this review with a trigger warning for spoilers.
The episode opens with a flashback to Oswald Cobb's childhood, setting the stage for a chilling exploration of his relationship with his mother. The dynamic between the two is unsettling, with Oswald treating his mother more like a romantic partner than a parent, despite being just a young boy. This pseudo-incestuous tone is not only disturbing but also a clear indication of the warped family dynamics that shaped Oswald into the man he would become.
The haunting sequence where young Oswald locks his brothers in a sewer and leaves them to their fate is a pivotal moment in understanding his character. As rain pours down outside, Oswald cuddles with his mother on the couch, watching a movie. His mother's concern for the other children is met with Oswald's reassurances, but his true feelings are revealed as he looks out the window, secretly reveling in the knowledge of their suffering. This scene cements Oswald as a monster, devoid of any redeeming qualities.
Credit must be given to Ryder Allen, the young actor who plays Oswald in these flashbacks. He captures Colin Farrell's mannerisms with uncanny precision, making the young Oswald feel like a genuine extension of the adult character. Each satisfied smile at the window is both nauseating and masterfully executed.
Francis Cobb, played by Dierdre O'Connell in the present and Emily Meade in flashbacks, is another major player in this episode. Initially expected to be killed off, Sofia's decision to keep Francis alive provides a fascinating dynamic between the two women. Francis' lucidity fluctuates, and there are moments where she seems to suspect Oswald's involvement in her other sons' deaths. When lucid, Francis is cruelly aggressive towards Sofia, challenging her to question her own motives and actions, drawing parallels to her father's influence.
The younger Francis, portrayed by Emily Meade, captures the frightened yet genuinely loving side of her character. She is aware that something is amiss with Oswald, but her maternal instincts prevent her from fully confronting the truth.
"Top Hat" is not just a character study; it's also an action-packed episode. Salvatore and his gang attack Oswald's operation, leading to a brutal fistfight between the two gang leaders. This fight is one of the best in the series, showcasing the raw intensity of the conflict between these two titans of Gotham's underworld. The episode takes several unexpected turns, all of which lay the groundwork for an exciting and unpredictable finale.
"Top Hat" is a masterclass in character development and storytelling. It takes the audience on a journey through Oswald Cobb's past, revealing the monstrous nature that has been hinted at since the beginning of "The Batman." The performances, particularly by Ryder Allen and the two actresses portraying Francis Cobb, are exceptional. This episode will leave viewers with a deeper understanding of Oswald's character and a sense of anticipation for the final episode of the season. It's a must-watch for fans of "The Penguin" and a testament to the show's ability to delve into the darkest corners of its characters' psyches.